Skip to content

How to Fix One Shoe Bigger Than the Other

Do you ever notice that one of your shoes feels snugger than the other when you’re wearing them? It’s not uncommon for people to find that their feet are different sizes, and it can be extremely annoying if there seems to be a size difference between your two shoes. Fortunately, there are some simple solutions so that both of your feet feel comfortable in their respective shoes. In this post, we’ll go over the different methods about how to fix one shoe bigger than the other.

How to Fix One Shoe Bigger Than the Other

If you find yourself in the unusual predicament of having one shoe that is larger than the other, don’t despair! Though it may seem like an issue you cannot resolve, there are a few creative solutions available to help make this uncommon plight more manageable. With some careful tweaking and fitting adjustments, we can ensure your shoes will fit comfortably again and avoid any embarrassing missteps or walking difficulties. Read on to learn more!

What Can Cause One Shoe Bigger Than the Other Problem?

There are many reasons why a shoe might fit oddly. Such as:

1. Different-sized Feet

One of the most common causes of having a shoe that is too big or too small is having different-sized feet. If one foot is larger than the other, it can make finding shoes that fit properly quite challenging.

2. Poorly Fitting Shoes

Another common cause of unevenly fitting shoes is simply wearing shoes that are not the right size. If a shoe is too big or too small, it can cause the fit to be uneven and lead to shoes that rub in funny places or one shoe feeling much tighter than the other.

3. Poorly Made Shoes

In some cases, even if you are wearing shoes that are the right size, they may not fit properly due to poor construction or materials. For example, if the shoes are made with poor-quality materials that do not stretch well or give enough support, they may result in one shoe feeling too loose and the other feeling uncomfortably tight.

You Are Wearing Shoes 
That Are the Right Size

10 Ideas on How to Fix One Shoe Bigger Than the Other

1. Invest in a Quality Shoe Stretcher

One of the most common and effective ways to fix a shoe that is bigger than the other is by investing in a quality shoe stretcher. This tool can be used to gently stretch out your shoes, helping them conform to the shape of your feet more easily.

2. Use Boot Trees

Another great way to make sure your shoes fit properly is by using boot trees, which are designed to help maintain the shape of your shoes and keep them from becoming misshapen over time. So if you have a pair of shoes that tends to be a bit on the larger side, using boot trees may help keep them from getting bigger.

3. Wear Socks with Your Shoes

One simple way to counteract excess width on one shoe is by wearing thicker socks in that shoe. This can help to fill out the extra space and make your shoes fit more comfortably. So if you have one shoe that feels a bit snugger than the other, try wearing thicker socks to help even them out.

Wearing Thicker Socks

4. Get Custom Insoles

Another great way to ensure that your shoes fit properly is by getting custom insoles for your shoes. These can be made to perfectly match the shape of your feet, helping to make sure that your shoes fit snugly and keep you comfortable all day long.

5. Trim Your Toenails Regularly

In order to make sure that your shoes are a perfect fit, it’s important to take care of your feet on a regular basis. This means trimming your toenails regularly and keeping them in good shape so they don’t become too long over time.

6. See a Shoe Fitter

If you still struggle to find shoes that fit properly, it may be worth seeing a shoe fitter for assistance. These professionals can help you find the right size and style of shoes so that you can be sure to get a good fit every time.

7. Wear Patches or Heel Grips

If you have one shoe that seems to be a bit too large, there are a few other tricks you can try to help fill out the extra space. For example, you can use heel grips or patches that can help keep your shoes in place better and prevent them from sliding around as much.

You Can Use Heel Grips

8. Buy Shoes with Adjustable Features

If you have one shoe that is bigger than the other, it may be worth looking for shoes that have adjustable features or straps, such as velcro closures or laces. This can help to ensure a better fit and prevent your shoes from slipping around too much.

9. Consider Getting a Shoe Insert

In some cases, the best solution for one shoe being bigger than the other may be to get a shoe insert. This can help fill out any extra space in your shoes and make sure that they fit properly, even if one shoe is slightly larger than the other.

10. Rotate Your Shoes

If you have multiple pairs of shoes and find that one pair tends to be a bit on the larger side, it may be worth rotating your shoes regularly. This can help prevent anyone pair from getting too loose or worn down and can help you get better overall wear out of all your shoes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is One of My Shoes Bigger Than the Other?

One of the most common causes of one shoe being bigger than the other is a condition called hallux valgus, also known as bunions. This occurs when your big toe begins to lean towards your second toe, which can cause your shoe to not fit properly and feel uncomfortable. 

Other possible causes of one shoe being bigger than the other include poor foot mechanics, such as flat feet or high arches, and uneven pressure on your feet due to a heavy load.

Can I Fix One Shoe Bigger Than the Other on My Own?

There are a few things you can try at home to help correct one shoe being bigger than the other. First, you may want to consider investing in some insoles or orthotics that will help evenly distribute pressure across your foot and provide additional support for your feet. 

You can also try stretching out your shoes to help make them more comfortable, or purchasing a shoe stretcher if your shoes are still too tight. If none of these remedies work for you, it may be worth consulting with a podiatrist or other foot expert who can recommend additional treatments and solutions.

Should I See a Doctor if One Shoe Is Bigger Than the Other?

If you have tried various remedies at home and still find that one shoe is bigger than the other, it may be time to talk to your doctor. He or she can properly evaluate your feet and determine what sort of treatment options are best for you. This may include things like custom orthotics or other supportive footwear, as well as surgery to correct any underlying conditions that may be contributing to your problem.

Various Remedies at Home and Still Find

How Much Does It Cost to Fix One Shoe Bigger Than the Other?

The cost of foot care and treatment can vary depending on the specific needs of your feet. For example, if you simply need a pair of insoles or shoe inserts, this may be a relatively affordable option. However, more advanced treatments like surgery can be quite costly and may not be covered by your insurance. That said, many clinics and healthcare providers now offer flexible payment plans to help make treatment more accessible to all patients.

Regardless of the specific treatment you need, it is important to get one shoe bigger than the other properly addressed as soon as possible in order to prevent any long-term negative effects on your feet and overall health. By following the tips above and working closely with your doctor, you can achieve better foot health and get back to doing the things you love.


Now you know how to fix one shoe bigger than the other. This simple guide can help you make your shoes feel more comfortable in just a few minutes, so you can get back to your day. Give it a try next time you notice that one of your shoes is giving you a bit too much room.

Although it may seem difficult to fix a shoe that is bigger than the other, there are some relatively simple methods that can be used to correct the problem. By following the steps outlined above, you should be able to make your shoes fit more snugly and comfortably. Do you have any other suggestions for how to fix a shoe that is too big? Let us know in the comments below!